Sattva SecureSattva Secure
All articles

Underinsurance: how the average clause quietly shrinks a fire claim

Published

A sum insured set years ago can cut a claim in proportion, even when the loss is small. Here is how the average clause works, and how to set values that hold up.

A warehouse floor stacked with crates of stock

Most fire claims that disappoint do not fail outright. They are paid — just less than the business expected. The usual reason is not a hidden exclusion but a number on the schedule: the sum insured.

What the average clause says

A property policy assumes you have insured the full value of what is at risk. If you have insured less, the insurer treats you as carrying the gap yourself, and every claim is reduced in the same proportion. That is the average clause.

Claim payable = loss × (sum insured ÷ value at risk on the day of the loss)

A worked example

A plant and its machinery are insured for ₹4 crore. On the day of a fire, the cost to replace them is ₹5 crore. A fire damages one line, and the loss is assessed at ₹50 lakh.

  • The property was insured for 80% of its value (4 ÷ 5).
  • The claim is paid at 80%: ₹40 lakh, before the deductible.
  • The remaining ₹10 lakh comes out of the business, although the loss was far below the sum insured.

Why values drift

Sums insured are often set when the policy is first placed and then renewed as they are. Meanwhile building costs rise, machinery is added, and stock grows with the business. Three years on, the schedule describes a smaller company.

Setting values that hold up

  1. Insure on reinstatement value for buildings and machinery — what it costs to rebuild or replace new, not the book value.
  2. Revalue at every renewal, and whenever you add a line, a floor or a warehouse.
  3. Use a declaration policy for stock that moves through the year, so the cover follows the stock you actually hold.
  4. Keep the workings. A valuation you can show the surveyor settles most arguments before they start.

If you are not sure how your current sums insured were arrived at, that is the first thing we review.

Let’s make your cover make sense.